The record cites worries approximately the community’s crash-susceptible node architecture. But Solana Labs has already refuted a few of the claims.
DeFi Safety, an independent DeFi score agency, has ranked Solana as the second one-worst in line with the company’s technical standards.
Axie Infinity’s, the popular play-to-earn gaming platform, Ronin blockchain has been ranked as the worst, in step with DeFi Safety. Ronin turned into hacked for $600 million in March 2022.
The Montreal-primarily based company has rated over 240 Decentralized Finance (DeFi) protocols and 15 one of a kind blockchains.
DeFi Safety’s blockchain evaluations consist of five-one-of-a-kind criteria: node remember and their diversity, supporting software, documentation, in addition to checking out and protection, in line with their weblog publish.
“DeFi Safety does not perform code audits,” explains Defi Safety on its about page. “Instead, we overview the first-class of procedure and documentation at the back of the code, of which audits are only a part.”
Why is Solana rated low?
DeFi Safety’s primary reasons for this type of low rating revolve around Solana’s negative node infrastructure and frequent downtimes.
Other motives consist of improper coping with of archival node data, poorly designed block explorers, and unaudited node customers (software) with less range than competing blockchains.
DeFi Safety raised issues approximately the lack of info concerning the network’s node archival, or the method of storing all of a blockchain’s information due to the fact its inception.
4/28 It is still unclear in which the chain shops its records – there had been no documented updates at the Solar bridge after data have been abandoned.
— DeFiSafety (@DefiSafety) June 7, 2022
There is no clean documentation on node archival besides a 12 months-antique Reddit thread from Anatoly, co-founder of Solana, in keeping with the rankings firm. Still, Austin Fedora, head of communications at Solana, stated that this isn’t essential for Solana.
“Solana does now not require know-how again to genesis to validate a block,” Fedora advised Decrypt.
As for node customers, DeFi Safety argues that Solana clearly doesn’t have enough services. A node purchaser is software program that facilitates users join their computers to a blockchain network with a view to validate and execute transactions.
Currently, Solana gives just one piece of software program for its node operators, which has now not been audited when you consider that 2019, claimed DeFi Safety. Ethereum, as an example, gives seven one of a kind execution clients and six consensus clients.
“Only one node implementation; that is correct and legitimate,” stated Fedora. “Solana Foundation is running to diversify validator customers.”
According to the report, Solana’s local block explorer, Solscan, also leaves a whole lot to be favored, specially while in comparison to that Ethereum’s Etherscan.
“Several top-tier block explorers are being constructed by means of the community most of the people of which might be much less than 18 months antique,” Fedora informed Decrypt. “In that point, their UX and functionality have greatly advanced to satisfy the desires of builders and users.”
The file also said that some Solana validators had begun censoring transactions. But Solana Labs denied this as nicely and known as it synonymous with miner extractible value (MEV) in Ethereum. MEV is any ancillary revenue that a miner can earn beyond prevailing block rewards and incomes gasoline prices by using converting the order of transactions.
“The electricity in any network rests in the validators,” Fedora informed Decrypt. “This discussion [DeFi Safety] became referring to become amongst several validators inside the discord channel. The foundation has no energy to censor any transactions.”
“We accept as true with Solana that Solana does not censor transactions. However, there has been dialogue of it,” Nick Sheaf the co-author of the DeFi Safety report advised Decrypt.
“Solana is spectacular and speedy and delightful but boy may want to things be achieved higher,” he concluded.
How reliable is the report?
The evaluation at the back of this file is based totally on standards set out through DeFi Safety.
Notable DeFi protocols along with Uniswap V3 (ninety six%), Compound Finance (93%), Aave (94%), and Bancor (ninety six%) are pretty rated for his or her improved transparency and protection.
Congrats for the @AaveAave Community for scoring in extraordinarily properly on organising nice strategies across the protocol 👏 👻
— stani.Lens (🌿,👻) (@StaniKulechov) June 7, 2022
The scores assignment additionally gave Terra’s Anchor Finance a more secure product score (75%) than Solana, which collapsed due to the protocol’s architectural failure.
Defi Safety also published a report on Badger DAO as ninety nine% safe in September 2021, which become later hacked for $120 million in December 2021.
The number one cause at the back of the deviation is that the Defi Safety report is primarily based on the project’s clever contracts. Instead, Badger Finance’s consumer interface was exploited.
Solana’s price action
Solana (SOL), the ninth-largest cryptocurrency with a market capitalization of $thirteen.Eight billion, is slightly up over the last day, trading at $39.09.
SOL is though down a whopping eighty five% from its all-time excessive of $260.06 recorded in November 2021, consistent with statistics from CoinMarketCap. Indeed, many of the top cryptocurrencies have shed large amounts of cost since the market’s back final 12 months.
The overall fee locked (TVL) on Solana is at $three.77 billion, up 1.07% over the past 24 hours, in keeping with information from DefiLlama.
For more information: